bcfg2-admin query doesn't get correct group membership

[Jim Rowan <[email protected]…>]

bcfg2-admin query g=ubuntu isn't listing all the members of the group ubuntu. The membership of ubuntu, in this case, come from inclusion in a dynamic group (ubuntu10-04) which ubuntu includes.

Indeed, the machine jmr-ubuntu is in the ubuntu group:

> showclient jmr-ubuntu.qualcomm.com
Hostname:       jmr-ubuntu.qualcomm.com
Profile:        q-desktop
Groups:         amd64
                ubuntu10-04
                q-desktop
                ubuntu
                ubuntu-lucid
                deb
                ubuntu-lucid-all-pkgs
                minimal
Bundles:        ntp
                bcfg2
                qc-desktop
                ssh
Connector data
================================================================================
Probes: {'groups': ''}
================================================================================

However, a query only returns the one machine that was directly included in the ubuntu group (this one client was defined that way).

bcfg# bcfg2-admin query g=ubuntu      
bcfg.qualcomm.com

But it does correctly know that many machines are in the dynamic group:

bcfg# bcfg2-admin query g=ubuntu10-04
(returns a bunch of machines, one of which is jmr-ubuntu)

The groups.xml file:

<Groups version='3.0'>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' default='true' name='basic'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
        </Group>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' name='desktop'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
        </Group>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' name='compute'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
        </Group>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' name='q-desktop'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
          <Group name='ubuntu-lucid-all-pkgs'/>
          <Bundle name='qc-desktop'/>
        </Group>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' name='s-desktop'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
          <Group name='ubuntu-lucid-all-pkgs'/>
          <Bundle name='qc-desktop'/>
          <Bundle name='s-dev'/>
        </Group>
        <Group profile='true' public='true' name='bcfg2-server'>
          <Group name='minimal'/>
          <Bundle name='ubuntu-server'/>
          <Group name='ubuntu-lucid'/>
        </Group>

        <!-- dynamic groups that gv/os_dist might spit out -->
        <Group name='ubuntu10-04' category='distro'>
          <Group name='ubuntu-lucid'/>
          <Group name='ubuntu-lucid-all-pkgs'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='sled10sp3' category='distro'>
          <Group name='suse'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='sles10sp3' category='distro'>
          <Group name='suse'/>
        </Group>

        <Group name='ubuntu-lucid'>
          <Group name='ubuntu'/>
        </Group>

        <Group name='minimal'>
          <!-- tiny set of things we handle for all machines -->
          <Bundle name='bcfg2'/>
          <Bundle name='ntp'/>
          <Bundle name='ssh'/>
        </Group>

        <Group name='ubuntu'>
          <Group name='deb'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='debian'>
          <Group name='deb'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='freebsd'/>
        <Group name='gentoo'/>
        <Group name='redhat'>
          <Group name='chkconfig'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='suse'>
          <Group name='chkconfig'/>
        </Group>
        <Group name='mandrake'/>
        <Group name='solaris'/>

        <Group name='chkconfig'/>
        <Group name='deb'/>
        <Group name='ubuntu-lucid-all-pkgs'/>
</Groups>

[desai]

This is resolved in [71bb583ac04ff1c52e03d69a91bbb508783566f8]